What Matters Most on the College Application? (2023)

What Matters Most on the College Application?

According to the National Association For College Admission Counseling (NACAC) the factors that admission officers use to evaluate applications from first-time freshmen have remained largely consistent over the past 20 years. Students’ academic achievements—which include grades, strength of curriculum, and admission test scores—constitute the most important factors in the admission decision.” NACAC’s report also highlights other important factors that colleges consider, including “the essay, a student’s demonstrated interest, counselor and teacher recommendations, class rank, and extracurricular activities.”

It goes without saying, colleges are looking for students who are intelligent, hard-working, and passionate about their studies, regardless of the specific attributes or skills they value. As a result, the focus of your college application should be on your strongest assets. For example, it's important to mention your love for the piano and how much you want to attend music school. You should mention this in several parts of your application, such as your personal statement.

A well-written college application will also demonstrate your genuine interest in the university. There must be a compelling reason for you to apply to college, right? If you're writing a "Why This College" essay, explain how you came to be interested in the school and why you think it's a suitable fit for your educational and career aspirations. College applications are designed to make you stand out from the crowd in a favorable and memorable way. In addition to key personality traits, such as ambition, passion, genuine interest, and academic curiosity, what looks really good on a college application?

Let’s dive in!

A strong application will often contain most or all of the following components:

  • A high GPA (compared to the average of admitted students) and a demanding curriculum
  • Good test results (relative to what admitted students have)
  • A concise, sincere, and well written personal essay
  • A distinct extracurricular passion or interest
  • Volunteer work with measurable results
  • letters of recommendation that are persuasive and written in your favor
  • Work experience, especially jobs that are relevant to your academic or career interests

Here’s what colleges look out for on your application:

1. Great Grades in Hard Courses

The most important component is unquestionably your transcript. Your performance in various topic areas with various teaching methods and grading standards is shown on your transcript. It is also known as the best indicator of college achievement. However, what matters most is that your GPA is greater than the average of admitted students at the college you are applying to, not just that you have a high GPA generally.

It is not simply your grades that count. Admissions officers also consider the quality and selection of the courses. You need to enroll in advanced courses in the subjects that interest you, not in all subject areas. Colleges also want to know that you intentionally challenged yourself by enrolling in harder classes, in addition to the fact that you did so. You are unable to change the past. But starting right now, you can alter your future.

Your application should highlight an upward grade trend, even if you started out in high school with lesser marks. This indicates that you are able to bounce back from any setbacks and are prepared to put in the effort required to succeed in college.

2. High Test Scores

Scores on college admissions tests are the next most essential element in admissions, despite their position at the bottom of the list. Over the past few years, this landscape has evolved dramatically:

  • Students can submit the SAT or ACT for college admissions at most colleges. Some colleges are test-blind, though, and do not want to see test scores.
  • Although it is hard to say without knowing a student’s background, if a test score is a positive part of their application, they should submit it. If the test score does not help their application and the college is test-optional, do not submit it.

One way for students to find out their percentile percent on the SAT and ACT is to take practice tests. It is now possible for them to concentrate on the test that they perform better on.

Free SAT prep is available through Khan Academy. The ACT offers free prep and tutoring for its test. Also, the high school and public library may offer test prep. School counselors will have specific suggestions. You should aim for a SAT/ACT score that will get you into all of the universities to which you're applying, since you're most certainly applying to more than one. Make a list of all the colleges you're considering for which you'd like to achieve a specific GPA.

3. Write a Sincere, Personal Essay

In your college application, the personal statement is one of the few places where you may truly express yourself. The 2019 NACAC poll found that 56% of schools place a moderate or substantial value on the essay portion of the application process. Despite the fact that some universities do not require an essay, those that do often place a moderate amount of significance on them. Colleges are looking for information in your essay that is not readily apparent from your application.

Generally, colleges are looking for three main qualities in a personal essay:

  • Honesty: What you write about should have genuinely occurred and should be how you actually feel. Exaggerating information and plain lying are significant no-noes here!
  • Specificity: Using clear details to successfully portray your thoughts, view, and experiences can make your essay a lot more memorable, personal, and—most importantly—unique.
  • Eloquence: Make sure your essay is not poorly written and full of grammar and spelling issues. A perfect personal statement has a rational organization, offers a captivating tale, and is absolutely devoid of technical faults.

How you write your college essay will depend on the prompt(s) your school gives you or the prompt(s) you choose (for example, the Common App and Coalition App allow you to choose from among several prompts for your essay).

What Matters Most on the College Application? (2)

4. After School Activities

You'll be asked this question by nearly every college you apply to about your extracurricular activities and interests. In fact, 49% of institutions questioned place a moderate or substantial value on students' extracurricular activities. Take a moment to think about what you enjoy doing outside of school. As a candidate, you should focus on one or two of your most cherished interests and highlight any notable accomplishments you've made in those pursuits rather than a long list of random activities. Say, for example, that you want to study science, technology, engineering, or math (STEM). If you have a lot of biology or science experience, that will make you stand out as a candidate. You might be in the biology club at your school or have volunteered at a local research lab, which taught you how to use lab equipment.

You want to show that you have a lot of different experiences and enough background knowledge in the field. You also want to highlight any major accomplishments that are relevant to the job. For example, you may have won a science fair in your sophomore year of high school. More recently, you may have entered a national contest with an invention idea that won an award.

5. Recommendation Letters

Most colleges want you to have at least one letter of recommendation from a high school teacher or counselor (or both).

If you need a letter from a teacher, choose someone in whose class you did well (ideally got an A) and who knows about your skills, goals, and interests. Usually, you'll need to send at least one letter from a teacher who taught a core class, such as math, English, science, or social studies/history. A letter from a teacher who works in the field you want to major in is also a good idea. So, if you got an A in AP English and want to major in English, asking that teacher for a letter of recommendation would help your application a lot.

You don't have to be best friends with the teacher you ask, but they should know you well outside of the classroom so they can tell admissions committees what makes you special, or why they should let you in.

6. Experienced Volunteering With Measurable Impact

Colleges appreciate applications from candidates who have not only volunteered but have had a demonstrable impact. The group, community, or region you were trying to aid should have undergone a discernible, positive change as a result of your support if you have volunteered somewhere or for an organization.

Think about the neighborhood city hall where you volunteered, for instance. Perhaps you had the notion to organize a “build it together” campaign since the city hall was having trouble raising money to keep running. The amount raised by the fundraiser—more than $3,000—would serve as a tangible measure of the beneficial effect your service had on the hall. So you may specifically note how your initiative caused the hall to stay open in your college application.

7. Work Experience

Having some work experience on your college applications, particularly any jobs that are connected to what you want to study or do professionally, will help you stand out in a positive way even though you are not needed to take a part-time job while in high school.

Any (part-time) work experience you have will be great to list on your application, even if it is unrelated to a long-term academic or career goal you have, as it highlights your sense of responsibility, maturity, and willingness to work toward your objectives—qualities that are frequently regarded as crucial for success in college.

Before You Begin Your Application

Make sure you are not responding in a general way that might apply to any college or giving unimpressive data from the website if a college asks, as they frequently do, "Why do you want to attend our college?" Never inform a college of something they already know. They wrote it before you did, so you know they are aware of it.

Do not forget these tips:

  • Comb through the college's website thoroughly
  • Visit the school, whether in person or online
  • Speak with current and former students
  • Check out the college's official social media channels and read the online student newspaper

Before You Submit Your Application

Use your school email account or create a regular email address for your applications; be professional and avoid anything that can detract from your application.

It is a fact and a characteristic of people that, until you arrive on campus, and begin your first day of classes, people will judge you on the basis of your transcript, your essay, your activities, your recommendations, your supplements, and, possibly, your test scores. You can do this! Finally, while you begin the process of applying to colleges and brainstorming ideas for your personal statement, keep in mind the following facts regarding the application process:

Do no forget these tips:

  • Instead of being perfectly round, it is better to stick out.
  • There's no avoiding essays! They are really important
  • A B score in a hard course is more impressive than an A score in an easy course
  • Even if your application isn't perfect, you can still get into the school of your dreams

Want to Save *THOUSANDS* on College?

Avoid that crippling student loan debt with our Master College Funding Course! This course will cover everything you need to know on how to pay for college the RIGHT WAY and how to stay far away from any unnecessary college costs throughout your college journey. Click here for more information.

What Matters Most on the College Application? (3)

FAQs

What Matters Most on the College Application? ›

Courses and Grades

A student's grades in college-preparatory classes remain the most significant factor in college admission decisions.

What matters most in a college application? ›

Courses and Grades

A student's grades in college-preparatory classes remain the most significant factor in college admission decisions.

What makes you stand out on a college application? ›

Stand-out applications showcase achievement, merit, and previous academic success. Taking honors classes or AP courses can give you a significant advantage. Most colleges generally prefer applicants with a B in an honors program over those with an A in standard courses because it shows initiative.

What do colleges look for in short answers? ›

In short, admissions counselors are looking for students who can think for themselves. They want to see that you are open to new ideas and can support your opinions with thoughtful explanations.

What are the 5 most important things to consider when choosing a college? ›

Before making your choice, consider these factors: cost, location, size, your interests, campus life, graduation rates, and the potential return on your investment. Once you make your decision, be sure to commit to the college by the deadline.

What are 3 factors top colleges look for? ›

Good grades, a challenging high school curriculum, standardized test scores, extracurriculars, and a strong essay are a few key factors admissions officers assess. Each university may emphasize different elements of the application process.

Is essay or GPA more important? ›

State schools tend to screen candidates first using GPA and test scores, before reviewing extracurricular activities and essays. At these schools, essays matter less if you have particularly strong academics. The more selective the school, however, the more important essays are.

What makes you stand out example answers? ›

These can be professional skills, areas of expertise, personal qualities, or any relevant experience. Also, consider any impressive accomplishments from your past or career goals that speak to your commitment to the field. Think of ways to out-do the other candidates.

How can I increase my college acceptance rate? ›

  1. Earn Good Grades in Challenging Courses. ...
  2. Get a High SAT/ACT Score. ...
  3. Write a Compelling Personal Statement. ...
  4. Demonstrate Interest. ...
  5. Secure Strong Letters of Recommendation. ...
  6. Apply to a Diverse Selection of Colleges. ...
  7. Opt for an Early Admission Plan. ...
  8. Manage Your Online Reputation.

What do colleges look at in essays? ›

Colleges look for three things in your admission essay: a unique perspective, strong writing, and an authentic voice. People in admissions often say that a great essay is one where it feels like the student is right there in the room, talking authentically to the admissions committee!

What average do colleges look at? ›

If you want to attend a top college, exceptional grades can help you get accepted. But the question is: what grades do colleges look at? Simply put, the answer is all of them. Colleges use your unofficial transcript to review your final grades.

Do colleges look at W's? ›

Pro: A “W” (Withdrawal) is Better Than Failing

Failing a class can negatively affect your academic record and future opportunities. In addition, when universities look at a “W” on a transcript, they are more lenient than if there is a series of “F” grades.

What 4 major factors should you consider when finding the right college fit? ›

Here are a few factors to get you started:
  • Public vs. Private. ...
  • Financial Aid/Loans. Financial aid can have a huge impact on a student's decision, and in fact, can be the leading factor. ...
  • Location, Location, Location. ...
  • Size. ...
  • Diversity, Equity, and Accessibility. ...
  • Research/Internship Opportunities.

What should I look for in a college checklist? ›

  • A CHECKLIST OF CONSIDERATIONS. WHEN CHOOSING A COLLEGE.
  • ACADEMICS.
  • AFFORDABILITY.
  • SUCCESSFUL OUTCOMES.
  • CAMPUS.
  • CAMPUS SIZE.
  • RESIDENCE LIFE.
  • ATHLETICS.

What are two important factors when it comes to deciding on a major in college? ›

Your major should align with future job opportunities, so it's essential to consider what it will be like to pursue a career in the paths you're interested in. In addition to earning potential, job growth, educational requirements, and skills are all relevant factors in determining what could be a good fit for you.

What five factors contribute to success in college? ›

Here are the five most significant factors in determining college success.
  • Defined Career Path. Successful college students do not enter their studies with an unclear and murky understanding of exactly what it is they would like to do in life. ...
  • Study Habits. ...
  • Social Skills. ...
  • Stress Management. ...
  • Self-Confidence. ...
  • About Author.

What affects college rankings? ›

Ranking Factors
  • Admissions Rate.
  • Enrollment Rate.
  • Full-Time Retention Rate.
  • Graduation Rate.
  • Number of Bachelor's Degree Graduates in the Given Subject.

What factors rank universities? ›

The most common metrics used for international university rankings are:
  • Academic reputation.
  • Student employment (usually measured 6-12 months post graduation)
  • Staff to student ratio.
  • International faculty ratio.
  • International student ratio.
  • Faculty research (staff members being actively involved in research)

Do colleges care about your past? ›

While policies do vary, colleges typically save applications for at least a couple years, and when a student has applied in the past, most admission officers will revisit the old application or at least parts of it.

Which GPA actually matters? ›

In general, admissions officers want to see more As than Bs, so having an unweighted GPA of above 3.5 can make a big difference.

Can you get into college with B's? ›

We have good news for you! Having a “B” average will not prevent you from attending a solid school that fits your unique self. In the guide below, we discuss how grades factor into college admissions and offer some tips to improve your admission chances.

What sets you apart from other applicants? ›

6 Ways You Can Differentiate Yourself from Other Candidates
  • Demonstrate That You are a Leader. ...
  • Show That You are Capable of Solving Problems. ...
  • Exhibit Strong Work Ethic Skills. ...
  • The Ability to Be Able to Work with a Team. ...
  • Excellent Communication Skills. ...
  • The Bottom Line.

What makes you unique from other applicants? ›

How to answer "What makes you unique?" Mention skills listed in the job description. Provide examples from your background. Reference prior accomplishments or results from past roles.

What is the best way to raise your GPA in college? ›

How to raise your GPA
  1. Avoid classes you don't need.
  2. Meet with a tutor.
  3. Speak with your instructors.
  4. Set goals for yourself.
  5. Turn in assignments on time.
  6. Join a study group.
  7. Study topics as you go.
  8. Improve note-taking skills.
Mar 10, 2023

Is it better to go to a college with a low acceptance rate? ›

There's not really such a thing as a good or bad acceptance rate. In general, schools with low acceptance rates (lower than 10 percent) are more selective or have high standards, or have tens of thousands of students applying for relatively few spots.

Can you negotiate college acceptance? ›

While some institutions may offer their best option right away, many will hedge their offers, just like a typical negotiation. Typically, discounts come through need-based or merit-based aid.

What are 5 common admission essay mistakes? ›

College Essay Don'ts:
  • Don't: Use overly formal language and structure. ...
  • Don't: List everything you've ever done. ...
  • Don't: Be vague. ...
  • Don't: Tell instead of show. ...
  • Don't: Write about overcoming an obstacle if you haven't overcome one. ...
  • Don't: Focus on someone else. ...
  • Don't: Share your essay with too many people.
Apr 4, 2019

What do admissions officers want in a college essay? ›

In your application essay, admissions officers are looking for particular features: they want to see context on your background, positive traits that you could bring to campus, and examples of you demonstrating those qualities.

What do admissions officers look for in college essays? ›

Admissions officers look for students whose essays reveal their character and perspective through their real experiences, not contrived situations. Admissions officers say most essays they read are safe, generic and do nothing to make them remember or want to advocate for the students who wrote them.

What can you not write about in a college essay? ›

Many essays included things that you should not do in your college admissions essay including: Never rehash your academic and extracurricular accomplishments. Never write about a "topic" Never start with a preamble.

What 3 things need to be included in a college essay? ›

Here are some things you should definitely include in your college essay:
  • Why you want to attend this school – admissions committees want to know why you are interested in their program and what makes you a good fit.
  • Specific details about what interests you about the program and why you are a good fit.

How do you start off a college essay? ›

Start with an attention grabber. The very first sentence of your essay should be the “hook” or “grabber.” This sentence “hooks” readers or “grabs” their attention, making them want to read more. This first sentence should provide rich details, engage a reader's curiosity, or otherwise stand out from the rest.

What classes do colleges look at most? ›

Math, science, social sciences, foreign language, and English are the pillars of a high school's core curriculum. In the eyes of admissions officers, core courses are what make or break a transcript. These are the high school classes colleges look for on applications.

What year do colleges mostly look at? ›

Your first year and sophomore year affect your cumulative GPA, which is important to most colleges. However, a solid academic record in your junior year is likely to carry more importance with an admissions committee.

Which two questions are colleges trying to answer by looking at your transcript? ›

Which two questions are colleges trying to answer by looking at your transcript? Did you take challenging courses? Were you involved in clubs and/or sports?

Will one C ruin my GPA in college? ›

One C in your transcript will not greatly impact your GPA and if it is a rare occurrence some colleges will just consider it a fluke. Colleges will probably look past it if that is the only class you've ever really struggled with as reflected per your grades.

Is it better to get an F or W in college? ›

Failing is more unfavorable than getting a W. A failing grade in college can definitely impact your GPA if the class is not taken on a “pass/no pass” basis. A letter grade of “F” provides you zero points for your GPA, but still counts as a class that is divided by the total points you earn.

What 5 things do colleges look at when choosing students? ›

Good grades, a challenging high school curriculum, standardized test scores, extracurriculars, and a strong essay are a few key factors admissions officers assess. Each university may emphasize different elements of the application process.

What are the top 5 criteria you would use in selecting a college? ›

Top 10 Factors for Choosing a College
  • Safety.
  • Academic Support and Career Services. ...
  • Campus Life. ...
  • Athletics and Extracurricular Activities. ...
  • Majors and Minors. ...
  • Class Size. ...
  • Cost and Fees. ...
  • Location and Distance From Home. ...

What are 5 things to consider when deciding on a college? ›

Before making your choice, consider these factors: cost, location, size, your interests, campus life, graduation rates, and the potential return on your investment. Once you make your decision, be sure to commit to the college by the deadline.

What to avoid when looking for colleges? ›

To help you confront this challenge, here are 10 mistakes to avoid when deciding which college to attend.
  • Not taking enough time. ...
  • Choosing a college for its reputation. ...
  • Not visiting the campus. ...
  • Overemphasizing your current major. ...
  • Not applying because of cost. ...
  • Thinking you won't qualify for financial aid. ...
  • Missing deadlines.
Jul 15, 2021

What qualities do colleges look for? ›

Here are 9 character traits that colleges often cite when they describe what they are looking for in students.
  • Curiosity. ...
  • Persistence. ...
  • Risk-taking. ...
  • Compassion. ...
  • open-mindedness. ...
  • Social Consciousness. ...
  • Creativity. ...
  • Collaboration.

What is the most important thing colleges look at? ›

Courses and Grades

A student's grades in college-preparatory classes remain the most significant factor in college admission decisions.

What 3 factors are most important for student success in college? ›

Factors That Influence a Student's Success in College
  • Family and Peer Support. No matter how independent the student, successfully transitioning into college often begins with strong family support. ...
  • Academic Habits. ...
  • Life Skills. ...
  • Decision-Making.

What should I do to make my college application better? ›

  1. Earn Good Grades in Challenging Courses. ...
  2. Get a High SAT/ACT Score. ...
  3. Write a Compelling Personal Statement. ...
  4. Demonstrate Interest. ...
  5. Secure Strong Letters of Recommendation. ...
  6. Apply to a Diverse Selection of Colleges. ...
  7. Opt for an Early Admission Plan. ...
  8. Manage Your Online Reputation.

What do colleges look for in application essays? ›

Colleges look for three things in your admission essay: a unique perspective, strong writing, and an authentic voice. People in admissions often say that a great essay is one where it feels like the student is right there in the room, talking authentically to the admissions committee!

What awards look good on college applications? ›

Examples of academic awards include, but are not limited to:
  • AP Scholar.
  • Any “honor society” such as, International Thespian Society, National Honor Society, etc.
  • Honor Roll.
  • National Language Exam Recognition.
  • National Merit Award.
  • President's Award.
  • School subject-based award.

What not to write in a college application? ›

Many essays included things that you should not do in your college admissions essay including:
  1. Never rehash your academic and extracurricular accomplishments.
  2. Never write about a "topic"
  3. Never start with a preamble.
  4. Never end with a “happily ever after” conclusion.
  5. Never pontificate.
  6. Never retreat into your thoughts.

How do I make my college resume stand out? ›

7 Ways to Boost Your Resume as a College Student
  1. Complete an internship. ...
  2. Get a summer job. ...
  3. Take online classes and earn certifications. ...
  4. Become a Resident Assistant (RA). ...
  5. Volunteer. ...
  6. Join professional associations and clubs. ...
  7. Study abroad.

How do you get colleges to notice you? ›

How to Show Your Interest
  1. Build a track record of consistent contact. From college fairs to campus visits to personal interviews, take each opportunity to talk with the college representative. ...
  2. Make your case in supplemental application essays. ...
  3. Show you've really researched the college. ...
  4. Apply early.

Do college admissions read every essay? ›

Yes, every college essay is read if the college has asked for it (and often even if they did not ask for it). The number of readers depends on the college's review process. It will be anywhere from one reader to four readers.

What admissions officers look for in college essays? ›

Admissions officers look for students whose essays reveal their character and perspective through their real experiences, not contrived situations. Admissions officers say most essays they read are safe, generic and do nothing to make them remember or want to advocate for the students who wrote them.

Do colleges look at essay score? ›

In general, then, schools really look at the score, but it's not one of the most important parts of your application or even your SAT score. Your best bet if you are interested in a given school that requires the essay and you want more specific guidance how they use the essay is to call the admissions office and ask.

What is the highest recognition in college? ›

Generally, the highest honor in college is the valedictorian, followed by the salutatorian. As a group, the highest honor is summa cum laude. The next highest is the magna cum laude, and the third is the cum laude.

What rank do colleges look at? ›

Class Rank and Colleges

Some colleges that used to rely on class rank now use SAT scores and GPA. Most large state universities, however, still require applicants to report class rank (as do many scholarship programs) and rely on it to help sort through the high volume of applications received.

What is the highest honor in college? ›

Summa cum laude is for students who have graduated "with the highest distinction." There is no universal standard about GPA or other metrics for granting the honors, rather, it is up to each individual school or university, In some cases, individual departments may determine what constitutes the award.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

Last Updated: 14/01/2024

Views: 6582

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (46 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

Birthday: 2001-01-17

Address: Suite 769 2454 Marsha Coves, Debbieton, MS 95002

Phone: +813077629322

Job: Real-Estate Executive

Hobby: Archery, Metal detecting, Kitesurfing, Genealogy, Kitesurfing, Calligraphy, Roller skating

Introduction: My name is Gov. Deandrea McKenzie, I am a spotless, clean, glamorous, sparkling, adventurous, nice, brainy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.